How the American Dream Conflicts with True Discipleship

We often think the greatest threats to our faith are obvious doubt, distraction, temptation. But what if the real danger is something more subtle? What if the quiet pull of comfort, success, and material security has more power to shape us than we realize?

In America, we’re discipled long before we ever open a Bible. We are taught to hustle, to climb, to dream bigger, earn more, and never settle. We're told to chase success, define our worth by our productivity, and view material blessing as a sign of God’s favor. This narrative so ingrained it often feels invisible has crept into the Church. And slowly, without even realizing it, we've begun to confuse cultural values with kingdom truth.

It’s not just a contradiction. It’s a discipleship problem.

In Philippians 2, we see the radical way of Jesus: “Though he was in very nature God, he did not consider equality with God something to be used to his own advantage he made himself nothing he humbled himself by becoming obedient to death even death on a cross.” This is not a success story as the world defines it. Jesus stepped down. He served. He suffered. He gave everything away.

He didn't build a brand. He built a Kingdom.

And yet, in much of modern Christianity, the line between faithfulness and ambition has blurred. Financial security becomes the goal, not the gift. Influence is mistaken for integrity. And wealth is often quietly equated with wisdom.

According to a Barna study, 62% of practicing Christians say they believe that “God wants them to prosper financially.” And while God’s provision is real and His blessings are many, the danger lies in equating financial gain with spiritual maturity. Jesus had more warnings about wealth than almost any other topic not because money is inherently evil, but because of its power to possess us.

Jesus was clear: “You cannot serve both God and money” (Matthew 6:24). Yet we often try. We preach self-denial but model self-promotion. We talk about generosity but live with clenched fists. We say we want to follow Jesus but quietly structure our lives around a dream that looks a lot more like the empire than the Gospel.

Henri Nouwen once wrote, “The gospel radically subverts the presuppositions of our upwardly mobile society.” The life Jesus calls us to isn’t a gentle nudge it’s a completely different direction. It's not an upgrade. It's an undoing.

This confusion is evident in how churches operate. Many are structured more like corporations than communities. Metrics of success become about attendance, giving, social media followers. Pastors feel the pressure to be both spiritual leaders and brand managers. But in the process, something essential gets lost. The Gospel is not about bigger buildings or wider reach it’s about changed hearts and humble service.

When we disciple people in the language of hustle but call it “purpose,” we end up with believers who are burned out, anxious, and unsure why their spiritual life feels hollow. They love God but they've been taught to chase a dream instead of carry a cross.

It begins with asking better questions. Are we being shaped more by capitalism than Christ? Are we modeling the radical generosity of the early church or just baptizing consumerism with Bible verses? Are we building lives that point to the Kingdom or to our own platforms?

This doesn’t mean rejecting hard work or living in lack. Scripture affirms diligence and provision. But it does mean resisting the lie that more is always better and that success is the ultimate sign of God's blessing.

The Gospel calls us to something different to give freely, live simply, serve humbly, and love without condition. It invites us to live a life that only makes sense if Jesus is real.

If we truly want to reflect Christ, we must begin the uncomfortable work of unlearning the American Dream. It’s not about guilt it’s about alignment. Aligning our values, our decisions, our pursuits with the way of Jesus. Because you can’t disciple people into the Kingdom of God with the values of the culture. And you can’t call it obedience if it’s driven by fear of not having enough.

The American Dream isn’t evil. But it’s not the Gospel. And until we recognize that difference, we risk building lives that impress the world but miss the heart of God.

So let’s be brave enough to ask what’s forming us. Let’s trade hustle for humility, wealth for worship, and ambition for abiding. Let’s follow the One who didn’t just talk about surrender. He lived it.

If this stirred something in you, consider sharing it with someone else or subscribing to our newsletter for more honest conversations about faith and following Jesus in a noisy world.