Eight Encouragements for When You Feel Like Giving Up

Every season of ministry eventually brings it.

The email.

The meeting.

The hallway conversation that lingers long after Sunday ends.

Criticism.

Some pastors face it occasionally. Others feel surrounded by it steady, sharp, and wearying. When encouragement is rare and complaints are frequent, the question quietly grows: Is it time to step down?

If you are contemplating quitting whether the pastorate, ministry leadership, or another calling altogether you are not alone. Studies suggest that nearly 40 percent of pastors have seriously considered leaving ministry in recent years due to stress, discouragement, or conflict. Burnout is not theoretical; it is painfully real.

Yet before resigning, wisdom calls for careful triage.

Triage for the Weary Shepherd

When criticism comes, the first task is not escape but examination. Scripture repeatedly calls leaders to humility, courage, and discernment. Consider these eight counsels as stabilizing anchors before making life-altering decisions.

1. Are the Criticisms True?

This is the most important starting point.

Ask plainly: What part of this is accurate? Even exaggerated complaints may contain a kernel of truth. Psalm 139:23–24 models this posture: “Search me, O God, and know my heart.”

Invite trusted voices a spouse, fellow elders, seasoned mentors to help you evaluate. Proverbs 27:6 reminds us that “faithful are the wounds of a friend.” A humble heart is a protected heart.

If the criticism is largely untrue, respond with gentleness. As Paul writes in 1 Corinthians 4:12–13, “When reviled, we bless; when persecuted, we endure; when slandered, we entreat.”

2. Is the Criticism Serious?

Not all complaints carry equal weight.

Preferences about music style, clothing, tone, or minor habits are rarely grounds for resignation. Even Charles Spurgeon advised pastors to cultivate “a blind eye and a deaf ear” toward trivial grievances.

Ask: Does this concern rise to the level of spiritual harm? If not, let it go.

3. Is It Longstanding?

A single difficult week differs from a multi-year pattern.

Persistent, repeated concerns may signal deeper issues that need addressing. Or they may reveal a divisive spirit within certain members. Time often clarifies whether criticism reflects momentary tension or systemic dysfunction.

4. Is It From One Voice or Many?

A lone dissatisfied member does not equal congregational consensus.

However, when multiple mature believers independently raise similar concerns, wisdom urges attention. While numbers alone do not determine truth, repeated affirmation of the same issue deserves prayerful examination.

5. Is It Moral or Missional?

Moral failures demand swift and serious response. Scripture holds overseers to high standards (1 Timothy 3:1–7). If sin has compromised integrity, repentance and accountability are essential.

But sometimes the concern is not moral it is about gifting or season. Leadership effectiveness can vary across contexts. A pastor suited for revitalization may struggle in maintenance seasons, and vice versa.

This is often a matter of degrees, not clear categories.

6. Is the Issue Changeable?

Some weaknesses can be addressed through repentance, training, counseling, or rest. Others may reflect enduring personality traits or limitations.

The key question: Is growth possible here? If so, pursue it wholeheartedly.

7. Seek Wise and Godly Counsel

No shepherd discerns clearly in isolation.

Proverbs 11:14 teaches that “in an abundance of counselors there is safety.” Invite spiritually mature voices into your wrestling. Their perspective may reveal blind spots or reaffirm your calling.

Surveys consistently show that pastors with close peer relationships report significantly lower levels of burnout. Isolation magnifies discouragement.

8. Remember Your Identity Is Not Your Role

Perhaps the most stabilizing truth: your joy cannot rest finally in ministry success.

Jesus told His disciples in Luke 10:20, “Rejoice that your names are written in heaven.” Before you are a pastor, elder, or leader, you are a redeemed son.

If your joy is rooted in measurable fruit, attendance numbers, or congregational affirmation, criticism will devastate you. But if your joy rests in Christ’s finished work, criticism cannot uproot you.

How to Fight for Joy While You Decide

Even as you evaluate whether to stay or go, you must fight for joy in God. Discernment is clouded when the soul is depleted.

Here are eight ways to steady your heart.

1. Re-anchor in the Gospel

Galatians 2:20 reminds us that Christ “loved me and gave himself for me.” Not for your preaching performance. Not for your leadership success. For you.

Let that love recalibrate your soul.

2. Preach the Promises to Yourself

Second Corinthians 1:20 declares that all God’s promises are Yes in Christ. Hebrews 13:5 assures, “I will never leave you nor forsake you.”

Preach these daily. The weary shepherd must become his own preacher before preaching to others.

3. Pray for Sustaining Grace

First Thessalonians 5:24 promises, “He who calls you is faithful; he will surely do it.” Ask for daily endurance. Grace comes in portions fitted to each day.

4. Receive Encouragement

Hebrews 3:13 urges believers to “exhort one another every day.” Seek brothers who will speak courage into your calling. Ministry was never meant to be solitary.

5. Tend to Your Body

Chronic exhaustion distorts perception. Studies consistently show that sleep deprivation intensifies anxiety and emotional reactivity. Rest is not weakness; it is stewardship.

Walk outdoors. Exercise. Step into God’s creation. Elijah needed food and sleep before he needed fresh commission (1 Kings 19).

6. Immerse Yourself in Rich Spiritual Reading

The wisdom of past saints steadies present storms. Seasons of discouragement are not new. You walk a road worn smooth by many faithful servants before you.

7. Memorize Scripture on Guidance

Psalm 25 offers profound comfort: “He leads the humble in what is right, and teaches the humble his way” (Psalm 25:9). God guides the lowly, not the self-assured.

8. Refuse to Interpret Hardship as Divine Abandonment

Difficulty does not equal disqualification.

Some of the most fruitful ministries in church history were marked by sharp opposition. Faithfulness often feels costly before it feels fruitful.

Stay or Go, He Is Faithful

The decision to remain or resign is rarely simple. It may involve repentance. It may involve reconfiguration. It may involve stepping aside for the good of the church.

But here is the unshakable truth: God does not waste His servants.

If you are a square peg in a round hole, that does not mean the Craftsman made a mistake. It means He may be carving a different place for you.

The God who called you is the God who sustains you. Whether you stay in your present post or step into something new, He remains your Father.

Lift your eyes from the critics. Fix them again on Christ.

He knows.

He sees.

He will guide.

If this encouraged you, share it with a weary leader or subscribe to our newsletter for more biblical encouragement delivered to your inbox.