Why ‘Alpha Male’ Doesn’t Equal Godly Manhood

There’s a version of masculinity gaining ground in Christian circles and it looks more like bravado than Christ. He’s confident, commanding, and always in control. He talks tough, leads hard, and never apologizes for taking up space. He’s the so-called “Godly Alpha Male.”

He quotes Scripture. He talks about “biblical manhood.” He calls men to reclaim their homes and rebuke softness. He claims authority as a divine right, demands respect from his wife, and measures maturity in dominance, not humility.

But here’s the truth: this model of masculinity doesn’t reflect Jesus. It reflects fear, pride, and a deeply distorted gospel.

Alpha Isn’t in the Bible

The term “alpha male” wasn’t birthed in Scripture it came from flawed animal behavior studies, later discredited by the very scientists who promoted them. The original research, conducted on wolves in captivity, was misunderstood to imply a rigid, violent hierarchy. In the wild, those same wolves behaved as families, not dictatorships.

Yet the myth stuck. And in some Christian spaces, it evolved into a framework for manhood: real men lead, women submit, and questioning that structure is rebellion. That may sound biblical to some, but it’s more cultural than scriptural. It takes a worldly idea power as supremacy and slaps a Bible verse on top.

The result? A gospel of masculinity that prioritizes control over character.

Jesus Doesn’t Fit the Mold

When the people of Israel imagined a Messiah, they pictured a warrior-king. Someone who would conquer Rome and restore Israel’s glory. But Jesus defied their expectations. He didn’t come to dominate He came to serve.

In Matthew 20:26, Jesus rebukes His disciples’ thirst for status and says, “Whoever wants to become great among you must be your servant.” He turns the world’s definition of power upside down.

Philippians 2 takes it further. Jesus, “being in very nature God, did not consider equality with God something to be used to his own advantage.” Instead, He emptied Himself, taking the form of a servant even to death on a cross.

The most powerful being in the universe chose surrender. That’s not weakness. That’s divine strength.

Real Strength Looks Like Love

Today, many churches confuse leadership with dominance. They encourage men to be firm, authoritative, and emotionally guarded. But the Bible paints a different picture. Real strength is not cold or combative it’s courageous, gentle, and rooted in sacrificial love.

1 Corinthians 16:13–14 says, “Be on your guard; stand firm in the faith; be courageous; be strong. Do everything in love.” Courage and love aren’t opposites. True masculinity isn’t measured in how loudly you lead, but how deeply you love.

Jesus wept. He welcomed children. He listened to women. He healed the broken. He washed feet. He forgave enemies. He refused to wield power as a weapon.

And yet, He never stopped being strong.

The Cost of the Alpha Myth

This distorted version of masculinity is doing damage. It’s hurting women in marriages where “leadership” becomes control. It’s hurting men who feel like failures if they’re not naturally dominant. It’s hurting churches that elevate charisma over character and confuse hierarchy for holiness.

It teaches men that gentleness is weakness, vulnerability is failure, and power is proof of worth. But Christ says the opposite. He says the meek will inherit the earth (Matthew 5:5). He says His power is made perfect in weakness (2 Corinthians 12:9).

Men who are soft-spoken, artistic, sensitive, or anxious often feel alien in churches shaped by alpha culture. But what if they’re not failing? What if they’re actually walking more closely with Jesus than the loudest voice in the room?

Reclaiming Christlike Manhood

Jesus isn’t just our Savior He’s our example. And He didn’t come to play the alpha. He came to lay His life down. If our model of masculinity doesn’t look like Him, it’s time to rethink it.

Men of God are called to courage but also to compassion. To leadership but always as servant-leaders. To strength but strength expressed in humility, mercy, and grace.

The Church doesn’t need more swagger. It needs more foot-washers. Men who are quick to listen, quick to repent, slow to speak, and slower to anger. Men who know their worth isn’t in authority, but in identity sons of the living God.

So let’s be clear: the hyper-masculine, emotionally detached, control-driven alpha ideal is not the gospel. It’s a cultural distortion dressed in biblical language. And it’s time we stopped applauding it.

A Better Way Forward

We don’t need more dominant men. We need more Christlike men.

Men who are willing to kneel. Men who don’t fear emotions. Men who understand that real leadership is always sacrificial.

God isn’t asking men to be kings.

He’s asking them to be like Jesus.

If this message resonates with you or someone you know, share it or subscribe to our newsletter for more reflections on following Jesus with authenticity and grace.