Joy Is Both a Gift and a Command

Joy is one of those deep, mysterious aspects of the Christian life that feels both simple and complex. On one hand, we’re told over and over in Scripture to rejoice. “Rejoice in the Lord always” (Philippians 4:4), “Delight yourself in the Lord” (Psalm 37:4), and “Rejoice insofar as you share Christ’s sufferings” (1 Peter 4:13). These are not optional; they are commands.

But at the same time, joy is described as something that is given to us not something we manufacture. Paul calls it a fruit of the Spirit (Galatians 5:22), and in Romans 15:13, he writes, “May the God of hope fill you with all joy.” This joy flows not from effort, but from the Spirit of God working within us.

So, which is it? Is joy an act of obedience, or is it a spontaneous gift? The surprising answer is: it’s both.

The Paradox of Commanded Emotion

This paradox runs through much of the Christian life. We’re commanded to believe, repent, love, and rejoice but each of those is also described in Scripture as something only God can ultimately grant.

• Believe in the Lord Jesus, and you will be saved (Acts 16:31) — a command.

• It has been granted to you to believe in him (Philippians 1:29) — a gift.

• Repent, for the kingdom is at hand (Matthew 3:2) — a command.

• God may perhaps grant them repentance (2 Timothy 2:25) — a gift.

• Love one another (John 13:34) — a command.

• The fruit of the Spirit is love (Galatians 5:22) — a gift.

The pattern is consistent and unmistakable: God commands what we must do and then gives what He commands.

Why This Tension Exists

Why would God command emotions like joy, which seem to arise spontaneously, and yet also declare that these very emotions are His gift?

Because this tension glorifies God. When we obey God’s commands especially commands that reach deep into our hearts and feelings in His strength, He gets the glory. We get the help; He gets the praise.

This is foundational to the Christian life. First Peter 4:11 says, “Whoever serves, let him serve by the strength that God supplies so that in everything God may be glorified through Jesus Christ.” It’s not just our actions that matter, but how they’re powered. If we serve, believe, love, and rejoice in our own strength, the glory is ours. But if we live in daily dependence on God, relying on His Spirit, the glory is His.

What About Joy Specifically?

Joy, then, is both commanded and gifted because it flows from a heart that is both responsive and dependent. We are responsible to pursue joy in God, yet we cannot create it apart from His grace. As Christians, our joy is anchored in the greatness, beauty, and worth of God. It’s not rooted in circumstances, but in the unchanging character and promises of the Lord.

That’s why Jesus can command joy even in suffering: “Rejoice and be glad, for your reward is great in heaven” (Matthew 5:12). And Paul can say, “We rejoice in hope of the glory of God” (Romans 5:2). The joy isn’t fake happiness; it’s a supernatural response to eternal truths.

How Do We Live This Out?

We don’t manufacture this joy by sheer willpower. Instead, we follow a two-step rhythm: look and pray.

1. Look
   We open our Bibles. We read the promises of God, the works of Christ, the hope of glory. We fill our minds with truth about who God is and what He has done. Joy begins with right seeing seeing the world and our lives through the lens of God’s Word.

2. Pray
   We ask God to make our hearts feel what our eyes are seeing. Psalm 119:18 is a fitting prayer. “Open my eyes, that I may behold wondrous things out of your law.” We pray that the Spirit would awaken joy in us through the truth we’re beholding.

This is how we align our hearts with God’s commands. We don’t ignore His call to rejoice. But we don’t try to fake joy either. We look to Him, and we ask for joy that is real, Spirit-given, and rooted in truth.

The Joy That Glorifies

This kind of joy the kind that sees Christ and treasures Him is what glorifies God the most. It says to the world, “God is enough. He is satisfying. He is better than anything else.” That’s why joy isn’t just a happy feeling; it’s a declaration of God’s worth.

St. Augustine captured this so well in his prayer. “Give what you command, and command what you will.” God doesn’t lower the bar. He calls us to rejoice, to believe, to love. But He also bends down in mercy to lift us up to that calling. He gives what He commands.

If joy in God feels distant, don’t despair. Start by looking really looking at His Word. And then pray. Ask for joy. Ask boldly, because you’re asking for something God already wants to give you.

And in doing so, you’ll live out one of the greatest truths of the Christian life: we get the joy, and He gets the glory.

Share this with someone who needs encouragement in their joy today or subscribe to our newsletter for more reflections that help deepen your faith.