The Christian Post reports that a federal judge has ruled a Maine school board cannot deny a church a lease to meet in a public school because of the church's conservative social views. Chief U.S. District Judge Lance Walker of the District of Maine issued the decision and order on Friday in The Pines Church and Matt Gioia v. Hermon School Department.
The Pines Church of Bangor had applied to lease space at a high school in Hermon. The school board rejected the application after asking the church about its positions on same-sex marriage and abortion. Walker wrote that if a public school's facilities are available for public use, a religious organization cannot be denied access to them because it is a religious organization.
According to The Christian Post, Walker concluded that a majority of the board showed "bad motive" in rejecting the application and "violated the Plaintiffs' rights under the First Amendment." He criticized one board member's "intrusive questions" toward the church. The judge ruled that the district's treatment and denial of the church's request for a year-long lease violated the church's rights under the First Amendment and under Maine's public accommodations law.
Pastor Matt Gioia founded The Pines Church in 2021, and the congregation first met in a movie theater in Orono, Maine. As the church grew, Gioia looked for a larger space on a one-year lease. In May 2023, after the board turned the church down, the church sued Hermon school officials. In a statement released that year, Gioia said the church was disappointed with the process but not discouraged, and hoped to continue its worship and fellowship without discrimination.
Bob Tyler, president of Advocates for Faith & Freedom, the law firm that represented the church, said in an emailed statement that the ruling affirms a basic principle: when public schools open their facilities to sports teams, scouts and recreation programs, they cannot exclude churches because of their faith. A congregation needs a room to gather in, as Hebrews 10:25 reminds us not to forsake. The court says a church's beliefs cannot be the reason it is turned away.
Read Hebrews 10:25
