Navigating the Use of Nativity Sets in Light of Biblical Teachings

The holiday season often brings cherished traditions into our homes, with nativity sets being a prominent feature in many Christian households. These depictions of the birth of Jesus serve as visual reminders of the incarnation and the profound significance of Christ's arrival. However, some believers question whether such representations align with biblical teachings, particularly concerning the Second Commandment's prohibition against graven images.

Understanding the Second Commandment

Exodus 20:4–6 states:

"You shall not make for yourself a carved image, or any likeness of anything that is in heaven above, or that is in the earth beneath, or that is in the water under the earth. You shall not bow down to them or serve them..."

This commandment warns against creating and worshiping images or likenesses, emphasizing God's desire for His people to worship Him in spirit and truth, free from physical representations that could lead to idolatry.

Theological Perspectives on Images of Christ

Theologian J.I. Packer, in his book Knowing God, argues that the Second Commandment forbids not only the worship of false gods but also the use of images in the worship of the true God. He suggests that visual representations can obscure God's glory and mislead believers by conveying incomplete or false ideas about His nature.

Nativity Sets: Decoration vs. Worship

When considering nativity scenes, the key distinction lies in their use. If a nativity set serves as a decorative or educational tool, reminding us of the historical event of Christ's birth without becoming an object of worship, many believe it does not violate the commandment. The concern arises when such representations become central to one's worship experience, potentially detracting from the formless, spiritual nature of true worship.

Personal Convictions and Community Practices

Believers may arrive at different conclusions regarding the appropriateness of nativity sets. Some, like theologian John Piper, acknowledge the presence of these scenes in their homes as cultural expressions of the Christmas story, while remaining cautious about their role in personal devotion. Others may choose to avoid them altogether to prevent any risk of idolatry.

Guiding Principles for Consideration

1. Intent of Use: Reflect on whether the nativity set is merely a visual aid or if it holds a place of undue reverence in your spiritual practices.

2. Focus of Worship: Ensure that your worship remains directed toward God Himself, not any physical representation.

3. Community Sensitivity: Be mindful of how such displays might affect others within your faith community, especially those who may hold differing convictions.

Conclusion

The use of nativity sets during the Christmas season is a matter that requires thoughtful reflection and discernment. By examining our intentions and ensuring that our worship remains centered on God, we can celebrate the birth of Christ in ways that honor both our personal convictions and biblical teachings.

If this exploration has provided clarity, consider sharing it with others or subscribing to our newsletter for more insights into faith and practice.