Alabama has the strongest legal protections for faith-based nonprofits and Michigan the weakest, Decision magazine reports, citing Napa Legal Institute's 2026 Faith and Freedom Index. The fourth annual index rates 15 areas of law in all 50 states and Washington, D.C. Alabama scored 80%, Kansas 76%, Indiana 75% and Texas 71%, according to Decision. Michigan came in at 34%, Washington 38% and Massachusetts 41%.

EWTN News reports the index was released on Nov. 16 and shows more than half of states scoring below 50% on key measures of religious freedom. The index looks at state constitutional protections for religion, religious freedom for faith-based employers, and whether a state constitution includes a Blaine amendment, which bars public funding of religious education, EWTN News reports. In ranking Michigan last, the institute said the state has several laws that burden faith-based nonprofits, including a Blaine amendment, no state-level Religious Freedom Restoration Act and no protection for religious exercise during a state of emergency. The institute called Alabama one of the best places in the country to run a faith-based nonprofit, though Alabama's constitution also has a Blaine amendment.

Frank DeVito, Napa Legal's senior counsel and director of content, said in a press release that some of the most important laws for religious organizations are not the hot-button issues people expect. He pointed to stronger religious freedom restoration acts, religious exclusions from nondiscrimination laws, and proper exemptions from regulations and state taxes. These, he said, let religious groups focus on their mission instead of costly legal compliance.

Decision reports that some states improved since the 2025 index. Florida changed its nonprofit corporation law to state plainly that directors of a religious corporation may rely on priests, ministers and rabbis for advice on religious questions. Massachusetts raised the revenue level at which fundraising nonprofits must get a third-party audit from $200,000 to $500,000, and Rhode Island raised its audit threshold from $500,000 to $1 million.

The results did not always follow party lines. Decision reports that New York (55%) scored higher than Tennessee (54%), Oklahoma (53%) and North Dakota (51%). DeVito said New York has stronger exemptions from nondiscrimination laws in employment and public programming than Tennessee, and that a New York court found the state constitution gives wider protection for the free exercise of religion than the federal First Amendment. The institute said there are blue states with important protections for faith-based nonprofits and red states with much room to improve.

DeVito said the stakes are practical. Churches and religious groups educate children, often in poor circumstances, feed the hungry and help the most vulnerable, he said, and they do it with a level of love the government cannot match. The index is a quick way to see how your state's laws treat the churches, schools and charities you support, and a reason to pray for those in authority, as 1 Timothy 2:1-2 asks.

Read 1 Timothy 2:1-2

Photo: DXR (CC BY-SA 4.0), via Wikimedia Commons