Your Online Habits Are Reshaping Your Spiritual Life

You already know your screen time is high. You may have even joked about your daily hours on Instagram or TikTok. But what if the real danger isn't just the distraction or the doomscrolling? What if your soul is quietly being shaped formed, even deformed by what you consume online?

According to Common Sense Media, Gen Z adults now spend an average of over four hours a day on social media. Pew Research reveals nearly 50% of U.S. teens admit to being online “almost constantly.” And Barna Group reports a growing number of young Christians turning to platforms like YouTube and Instagram for spiritual insight more often than they turn to Scripture or the local church.

This isn’t just a time management problem. It’s a spiritual formation crisis.

Every scroll, every video, every opinion you absorb isn't just information it's formation. These quick, emotionally resonant bits of content shape your instincts, your moral compass, and even your theology. And most of the time, you don’t even notice it happening.

The Digital Flattening of Truth

Online, the complex becomes simplified. The sacred becomes stylized. Deep theological truths are compressed into 30-second hot takes. Certainty is rewarded, not humility. Nuance doesn’t trend. Confidence, even if misinformed, gets the views.

It’s easy to start feeding on opinions rather than God’s Word. Easy to start mimicking influencers instead of imitating Christ. And while it might feel spiritual, it's often more about vibe than truth.

We hear bold, absolute statements like “Jesus would never support that,” or “If your church isn’t posting about this, it’s not biblical.” Whether or not you agree, these posts begin to shape how you instinctively react not because you’ve studied the Bible, but because you’ve seen these messages enough times to believe them.

The Shift from Community to Pack

Dr. Russell Moore recently reflected on his own digital tendencies after reading Jaron Lanier’s Ten Arguments for Deleting Your Social Media Accounts Right Now. Lanier suggests that social media doesn’t just attract trolls it turns us into them. Online, we move from individual reflection to tribal performance. We enter what he calls “pack mode.”

In pack mode, we defend our echo chambers. We attack opposing voices. We post and comment in ways that secure our identity in a group, not in Christ. We stop seeking truth and start seeking approval.

Moore explains it this way “If I find my identity in the community, or in the community’s perception of me, I am no longer free to serve the community.” This is spiritual drift. Your beliefs start aligning with your followers, not your convictions. Your theology is tailored to be palatable, not prophetic.

The church isn’t immune to this. Moore draws a direct line from this behavior to the tribalism Paul warns against in 1 Corinthians: “I am of Peter; I am of Apollos.” Our churches fracture into camps, each claiming a more authentic Christianity, while missing the heart of Christ entirely.

Discipled by the Feed

Formation rarely feels like a moment it feels like a pattern. One moment you're exploring Christian content. A few weeks later, you’re quoting influencers more than Scripture. You sound spiritual but feel spiritually empty. You know how to “talk faith,” but not how to hear from God.

This isn’t always intentional. But intention isn’t the metric of formation attention is.

Who are you giving your attention to? Who is shaping your soul?

And it matters. Because spiritual formation isn’t just about what you believe it’s about who you’re becoming.

What You Need Instead

You don’t have to delete every app. You don’t need to disappear into a cave. But you do need to pause and reflect.

You need formation, not just affirmation. You need intimacy with God, not just information about Him. You need a real church community, not just a virtual tribe. One that knows your name, your story, and your struggles not just your highlight reel.

“You weren’t created for a hive or a pack,” Moore writes. “You were created for a church.”

This means grounding yourself in Scripture more than content. Engaging in prayer more than comments. Being present with people who walk with you, not just those who agree with you online.

So what now?

Audit your digital life. Ask yourself:

• Who am I letting disciple me?

• Am I shaped more by my screen than by Scripture?

• Do I spend more time listening to people who affirm me than to the God who formed me?

Christ is still speaking. But the volume of other voices might be drowning Him out.

Turn some of them down. Clear space to hear His. Because in a world where everyone has something to say, your soul still needs to listen to the only Voice that truly matters.

Share this with someone who might be searching for more than screen-deep faith or subscribe to our newsletter to receive reflections like this weekly.