Why Christians Struggle to Talk About Porn

For all the sermons, small groups, and purity pledges, there’s still a deafening silence in the Church when it comes to porn. Not silence in the form of neglect most Christians can recall youth group talks about "guarding your eyes" but silence in the form of honesty. Behind the warnings and the accountability software lies a deeper truth most Christians struggling with pornography never tell anyone.

Because the shame is too thick. The fear is too real. And the Church, all too often, hasn’t made room for real conversations.

The Statistics We Ignore

Porn isn’t a hidden issue anymore. It’s a shared secret. Barna research shows that 64% of Christian men and 56% of women under 25 admit to viewing pornography monthly. For many, it’s weekly. These are not rare confessions they’re common realities. And yet, church spaces still treat pornography as a "men’s issue," a fringe problem, or an embarrassing footnote.

Women who struggle often remain invisible. Men who do are shamed into silence. And no one feels safe enough to raise their hand.

This isn’t just a sexual crisis it’s a discipleship crisis.

Shame Is Not the Way

Christian culture has historically used shame as its weapon of choice when addressing sexuality. From purity rings to modesty talks, to marriage books that reduce intimacy to obligation, the message has often been if you struggle, something’s wrong with you. That framing doesn’t heal people. It isolates them.

Sheila Gregoire, author of The Great Sex Rescue, has spent years researching evangelical sexual teaching. Her findings are sobering. In her interviews, many women said they felt like “prostitutes” in their own marriages. Boys were told lust was inevitable, and girls were told their worth lay in preventing it.

What results is a toxic cycle: the more people are shamed, the more they hide. The more they hide, the more isolated they feel. And the more isolated they feel, the less likely they are to believe healing is possible.

Rebecca Lindenbach, Gregoire’s co-author, explains it bluntly: “A 13-year-old watches porn for the first time and thinks, ‘Well, I’ve done it now. This is my life.’”

That’s what shame does. It tells you the moment you fail, you are your failure. That there’s no redemption. No return. Just silence.

The Gender Narrative Is Broken

The Church has often addressed pornography through a narrow gender lens. Men are framed as lustful by nature, and women as passive gatekeepers or victims. This narrative not only dehumanizes both it also erases the real struggles of women dealing with porn themselves.

Gregoire points out that “sex in the evangelical world is seen primarily through a male lens,” where men are portrayed as having insatiable needs and women are responsible for meeting them. The result? Excuses. A husband turns to porn because “his wife isn’t enough.” A pastor falls and is treated as a cautionary tale, not a betrayal of trust. Meanwhile, women who struggle or suffer are left without language, support, or dignity.

But women do struggle. And their silence is compounded by the Church’s refusal to recognize it. This is not just a men’s battle. It never has been.

The Silence Isn’t Working

Fear-based purity campaigns may get teenagers to sign pledge cards. They may scare young adults into temporary compliance. But fear doesn’t change hearts. And it doesn’t build communities safe enough for confession.

A healthy theology of sexuality must be grounded in both grace and truth. Not a panic about sin. Not apathy. But a third way: one that acknowledges sexual desire as a God-given reality, and pornography as a distortion of it.

Sexual attraction is not sin. Lust that dehumanizes and detaches is. The Church must learn to hold that tension not to condemn people for desire, but to disciple them in how to steward it.

The Church Must Go First

What would it look like for the Church to finally lead the way in honest, shame-free conversations?

It would require leaders who admit they don’t have all the answers. Small groups where people confess what’s real, not what sounds spiritual. Parents who respond to difficult questions with grace, not panic.

Gregoire believes it begins with repentance not just from individuals who watch porn, but from the Church systems that have weaponized shame, distorted gender roles, and perpetuated silence. That repentance includes dismantling harmful teachings and building something better.

It won’t be neat. But it will be necessary. Because as it stands, many Christians still believe freedom isn’t possible. And that’s a lie the Gospel came to destroy.

There Is Still Hope

Here’s the surprising twist: despite it all, younger Christians are still showing up. According to Barna and Gloo’s State of the Church report, Gen Z believers attend church more regularly than baby boomers about 1.9 times per month compared to boomers’ 1.6. That’s not a decline; that’s an opportunity.

These generations are coming of age in the most sexually saturated, digitally connected era in history. They need a Church that doesn’t flinch, that doesn’t judge, that doesn’t shame. A Church that can look them in the eye and say. Yes, we know what you’re facing. You are not alone. And there is grace big enough for this too.

Because porn isn’t the unforgivable sin. It’s a prison Jesus came to break. But first, we have to stop pretending it’s not there.

This begins with one brave conversation. Then another. Then another. Until the silence finally breaks, and healing finally begins.

Share this with someone who’s been carrying the silence too long or subscribe to our newsletter for more truth-centered content each week.