Preachers Must Guard Against Speculation

Each week, pastors step into pulpits across the world with one goal: to proclaim the Word of God. Yet with every text comes questions sometimes many. What did this phrase mean in the original context? Was Paul alluding to Roman games? Could this phrase be referencing a cultural tradition or ancient hymn? In these moments of uncertainty, preachers face a decision: to speculate or to stay silent.

It’s a question Mark from Montana recently asked: how much speculation is too much in preaching? With commentaries offering possibilities, educated guesses, and phrases like “this may refer to,” it’s easy to feel the pull toward embellishing our sermons with detail that sounds insightful even if it isn’t provable.

But in an age where biblical authority is already under siege, the call to faithful preaching has never been more urgent. Speculation may entertain, but it cannot nourish. Only truth can.

Honesty Above All

The most essential trait in any preacher is not charisma, intellect, or even eloquence. It is honesty. If the pastor is not honest about the text, about what he knows and doesn’t know his ministry loses its foundation. The people in the pews cannot trust a shepherd who bends truth for effect.

That means a preacher must never state as certain what he does not actually know. To present uncertainty as if it were fact is not clever it’s deception. And God will not honor preaching that compromises His Word for the sake of sounding impressive.

This doesn’t mean pastors must list every theological dilemma from the pulpit. Sermons aren’t seminary lectures. But where the text is difficult or unclear, humility demands transparency. “I don’t know,” when said honestly, can carry more spiritual weight than paragraphs of forced interpretation.

When Interpretation Isn’t Clear

But what about gray areas? What if you’ve studied, prayed, compared Scripture with Scripture, and still arrive at more than one viable interpretation?

This is where careful, qualified explanation becomes crucial. A wise preacher can say:

“Here’s what I believe this means, and here’s why. But there are other faithful interpretations too, and here’s why some hold to them.”

This isn’t a retreat from truth it’s modeling how to handle the Bible with reverence and care. As Paul told Timothy, we are to rightly handle the word of truth (2 Timothy 2:15). That means resisting the urge to fill every silence with certainty.

And it also means helping your listeners see that God’s Word is rich and reliable, even when we don’t grasp every detail. Mature preaching embraces mystery without manufacturing meaning.

The Subtle Drift Toward Entertainment

Mark’s question also touches on a subtler temptation in preaching: using speculation to impress. This happens when preachers borrow from psychology, sociology, or ancient cultural theory to explain a text in ways the audience could never see on their own.

For instance:

• “Paul must have been a type-A personality.”

• “This was likely an early Christian hymn.”

• “Jesus probably meant this as a veiled political statement.”

• “This word in Greek could mean three different things, and here’s an intriguing possibility...”

Some of these insights may be true. Others may be purely imaginative. But if they are not rooted clearly in the text and supported by Scripture, then they are little more than theological guesswork dressed as exegesis.

This kind of preaching subtly shifts the center of authority. Instead of pointing to what God says, it becomes a platform for what the preacher finds interesting. And while it may fascinate listeners for a while, it cannot build lasting faith.

Paul warned about such approaches in 1 Timothy 1:4, cautioning against "myths and endless genealogies" which promote speculation rather than stewardship from God that is by faith.

Faith-Building Preaching Must Be Clear

Romans 10:17 says, “Faith comes from hearing, and hearing through the word of Christ.” That verse reveals why speculative preaching is so dangerous it undermines the very foundation of faith.

When a preacher fills his sermons with uncertain theories, even well-intentioned ones, he slowly erodes the sense of divine authority in the minds of his people. Over time, listeners no longer come to hear God speak through His Word they come to hear the preacher’s opinions.

But when sermons are grounded in Scripture when pastors wrestle over difficult passages, pray over their study, and preach what they can clearly show in the text God meets His people with life-changing truth.

This is what makes faithful preaching not only powerful, but beautiful.

A Word to Preachers

If you preach, remember this you are not an entertainer. You are not a TED Talk speaker. You are not called to be interesting you are called to be faithful.

Your people don’t need novel insights. They need nourishment. They need a sure Word from heaven, not your best guess. They need to see the glory of Christ, not the cleverness of your mind.

And when you encounter a difficult text, don’t be afraid to say, “I don’t know.” Then go home. Get on your knees. Study the Scriptures. Wrestle with God like Jacob at Peniel until He blesses you with clarity.

Then come back to your people not with dazzling conjecture, but with truth. The kind they can build their lives on. The kind they can face death with. The kind that echoes in eternity.

Share this with a preacher you know or subscribe to our newsletter for more articles that deepen your love for Scripture.