Preaching Must Pierce the Soul

When we talk about preaching today, many imagine polished oratory, clever illustrations, and a dose of humor. But for the Puritans, preaching wasn’t a performance it was surgery of the soul. They weren’t content with simply delivering biblical truth. Their goal was for that truth to land, to lodge itself deeply in the conscience, and to transform the hearer. They preached to pierce the heart.

The Puritans believed that a sermon wasn’t finished when the truth was merely stated. Like paint in a can, truth has to be applied. You don't just bring the can into the room and expect the walls to paint themselves. You need a brush, and you need to use it. Similarly, a nail resting on a plank doesn’t build a house until it’s driven home with force. That’s what preaching is meant to do drive truth home with precision and grace.

Truth That Cuts and Heals

Scripture itself demands this kind of preaching. Hebrews 4:12 tells us the Word of God is “living and active, sharper than any two-edged sword.” It divides “soul and spirit,” laying bare our innermost thoughts. Paul exhorted Timothy to use Scripture not just for teaching but also “for reproof, for correction, and for training in righteousness” (2 Timothy 3:16). Preaching, then, is not simply informing the mind it is confronting the heart.

This wasn’t a theoretical principle for the Puritans; it was central to their ministry. Men like Richard Sibbes, Thomas Brooks, and William Perkins structured their sermons around application. The sermon was only complete when the text had been thoroughly pressed into the hearer’s soul.

The Pattern of Application

The Puritans were not novel in this. They followed biblical patterns. Jesus himself was the master applier of truth. Whether talking to Nicodemus about new birth or revealing the Samaritan woman’s thirst for eternal water, Christ brought truth directly to the soul. The apostles, too, shaped their letters and sermons with personal, heart-piercing application warning, encouraging, correcting, and comforting.

This is why the Puritans didn’t preach for applause but for change. Their goal wasn’t appreciation it was transformation.

Application Is the Life of the Sermon

Application, to the Puritans, was not a postscript; it was the sermon’s heart. It was the moment when God's truth stopped hovering in the abstract and started landing in people’s lives. Thomas Brooks said, “Doctrine is but the drawing of the bow; application is the hitting of the mark.” That image is unforgettable. Without application, even the most profound truth lies dormant.

William Perkins, one of the fathers of Puritanism, offered a helpful grid in his book The Art of Prophesying. He identified seven categories of people in a typical congregation, ranging from hardened unbelievers to mature believers. Each group, he argued, required specific forms of application some needed instruction, others rebuke, still others encouragement or comfort. From this framework, Perkins derived a total of twenty-eight possible angles for sermon application, depending on spiritual condition and context.

This method ensured sermons were not generic. They were selective, specific, and soul-targeted.

Simplicity That Strikes

One of the hallmarks of Puritan preaching was its simplicity. They avoided ornate language because they wanted to make the truth accessible and clear. The goal was never to impress but to press the truth deep into the heart.

Their sermons followed a basic but powerful structure:

1. Textual Exposition – a brief explanation of the biblical text

2. Doctrinal Truth – the main principle drawn from the passage

3. Use – the application of that truth to the hearers' lives

This final section often the longest was where the sermon came alive. This was where Scripture reached into the thoughts, emotions, and behaviors of the audience. It told hearers how to think, what to believe, how to feel, and how to act in light of what God had said.

Forceful, But Never Harsh

Despite their forceful application, Puritan preachers were not harsh. They were pastoral. Their sharpness was like a surgeon’s scalpel, not a soldier’s sword. Their aim was healing, not wounding. Sibbes once said, “The bruised reed he will not break” (Isaiah 42:3), describing the tender heart of Christ. The Puritans carried that tenderness into the pulpit. They wielded the Word with power, but also with compassion.

Even their strongest rebukes were wrapped in hope. When they warned of judgment, they also extended the invitation to mercy. When they exposed sin, they pointed to the Savior. They knew, as modern studies show, that conviction without hope leads to despair. A recent Barna Group study found that sermons which emphasize both challenge and grace are more likely to lead to lasting life change. The Puritans were ahead of their time.

Preaching to Yourself First

No Puritan preacher dared apply a sermon to others without first applying it to himself. John Owen warned, “He that doth not feed on and thrive in the digestion of the food which he provides for others will scarce make it savoury unto them.” In other words, if the Word does not first change the preacher, it will not change the people.

The preacher must be the first hearer of the sermon. Only then can he preach with conviction, humility, and authority. Only then can he bring the Word with power.

Why This Still Matters

In an age where so much preaching is therapeutic, vague, or entertainment-driven, the Puritan model of soul-piercing preaching is more needed than ever. Truth must not only be proclaimed it must be applied. It must aim not just for the ears, but for the heart.

A 2023 Lifeway Research survey found that only 34% of regular churchgoers could recall the main point of the previous week’s sermon. Why? Perhaps because the sermon didn’t stick. Application makes truth memorable. Application makes it matter.

Faithful preaching must cut, comfort, correct, and call. It must challenge the believer and awaken the sinner. As James Durham rightly said, “Application is the life of Preaching.”

So whether you’re behind the pulpit or in the pew, don’t be content with sermons that inform. Look for those that transform. Seek the Word that pierces not to destroy, but to heal. Because preaching isn’t done when truth is declared. It’s done when truth is delivered to the soul.

If this message stirred something in you, take a moment to share it with someone or subscribe to our newsletter to receive more articles like this.