All Believers Are Priests

When Martin Luther looked at the medieval church of his day, he saw a towering division between “the clergy” and “the laity.” Only the ordained could perform sacraments. Only the priests were considered holy. Everyone else was assumed to dwell in a lower, profane realm. Luther came to reject that division, insisting instead in the doctrine of the priesthood of all believers. This teaching is still urgent today both to recover the dignity of every Christian and to avoid the errors of radical individualism.

Luther’s Rebellion Against the “Spiritual Class”

By 1520, Luther was convinced that the church of Rome had elevated clerics into a spiritual aristocracy. The priests alone, it was said, had access to divine mysteries and could mediate God’s grace. The rest of the people a “temporal estate” were left servants of ritual, dependent and passive.

Luther rejected this. In his Works (54:111), he described the people of God as like a drunken peasant: tilt him one way, he falls; tilt him the other, he falls again. The medieval clerics thought they were the ones keeping the people upright, but in truth they had destabilized all of Christendom.

Luther proclaimed that all Christians are of the spiritual estate no one is left outside God’s holy calling. He wrote:

“All Christians are truly of the spiritual estate, and there is no difference among them except that of office.”
“Whoever comes out of the water of baptism can boast that he is already a consecrated priest, bishop, and pope, although of course it is not seemly that just anybody should exercise such office.”
Works, 44:127–129

He drew from 1 Peter 2:5, 2:9, and Revelation 5:10, showing that believers are built into a spiritual house and are called to offer spiritual sacrifices, to “proclaim the excellencies” of God, and to reign as priests under Christ.

Thus the medieval split between “holy clergy” and “profane laity” was a human invention not a biblical one.

The Tension between Equality and Distinction

While Luther struck down the clerical–lay divide, he did not collapse all distinctions. He affirmed that though all believers share in the priesthood, not all believers have the same office, gift, or role. One might preach; another might teach; another might serve, govern, care, encourage.

Unfortunately, in the wake of the Reformation (especially in the West), a new imbalance emerged: radical individualism. In some evangelical traditions, the doctrine was turned into “the priesthood of the believer” a privatized spirituality in which every man claims equal authority over doctrine, practice, and church life. As one historian put it: “every man’s hat is his own church.” (Winthrop Hudson, Baptists in Transition)

In this distorted version:

• The role of the pastor or elder becomes optional at best.

• The authority of the church and oversight are weakened or rejected.

• Each believer becomes final arbiter of interpretation, doctrine, and practice.

That was never Luther’s intent. He insisted: “no one must push himself forward … to do that for which we all have equal authority.” Works, 44:129

He clearly maintained that God arranges diversity of gifts and offices (1 Corinthians 12:18), and that distinctions are for the good of the community, not for hierarchy or status. Works, 44:130

Why the Doctrine Still Matters

1. Restoring Dignity to All

Too often, lay Christians feel passive or second-class merely spectators in worship. The priesthood of all believers reminds them: you are a participant in God’s redemptive work. You offer prayer, worship, service, witness these are sacramental functions in your everyday life.

2. Guarding Against Lone-Wolf Christianity

If every believer claims absolute autonomy, we risk atomizing faith churches become loose gatherings of individuals, not covenant communities. The gospel does not call us to solo spirituality; it calls us into a body. We are priest to one another, serving, correcting, encouraging, and standing with each other.

3. Upholding Biblical Order in Roles

True equality in spiritual standing does not collapse the diversity of ministry. Some are gifted to teach, to lead, to equip, to shepherd. Others are gifted to serve, to show mercy, to administrate, to care. These distinctions offices and roles are God’s design for flourishing church life, not relics of hierarchy.

Balance on the Saddle

Luther warned that if you put a drunken peasant into a saddle, he’ll fall off either side. The Reformation’s doctrine was meant to push us forward, not to collapse into individualism or clericalism.

We must preserve both truths:

• All Christians are priests, equally beloved, empowered, and called.

• Not all Christians exercise the same office, and we do well to respect biblical roles and structure.

When we get that balance right:

• The laity reclaim ministry.

• Pastors shepherd humbly, not lordingly.

• The church functions as a living organism, interdependent and rooted in confessional confession.

So, are all believers priests? Yes. But we are priests to one another, under Christ, in organized, loving service not independent islands. May we reclaim that truth in our time, riding closer to the saddle, not falling off either side.

If this was helpful, consider sharing it or subscribing to our newsletter for similar reflections.