The Role of Shame: Helpful or Harmful?

Shame can be a difficult emotion for Christians, often misunderstood and viewed as purely negative. However, in the Bible, shame serves distinct roles, some of which can be spiritually beneficial if properly understood. The key distinction we must make is between "misplaced shame" and "well-placed shame."

Misplaced Shame: What to Discard

Misplaced shame arises when we feel ashamed of honoring God or proclaiming Christ. For example, Paul warns Timothy not to be ashamed of the gospel or of suffering for it (2 Timothy 1:8). Christians should reject this type of shame because it stems from fearing human judgment, not God's opinion. Jesus also emphasizes in Mark 8:38 that we must not be ashamed of Him and His words, despite society's disapproval. This kind of shame can suffocate our witness for Christ.

Peter reinforces this in 1 Peter 4:16, urging believers who suffer for their faith not to be ashamed, but instead to glorify God. The message is clear: Christians should never feel shame for anything that exalts God, no matter how foolish it seems in the world's eyes.

Well-Placed Shame: A Tool for Repentance

On the other hand, the Bible shows that shame can serve as a powerful tool for repentance and restoration when placed correctly. Paul speaks to this kind of well-placed shame in 1 Corinthians 6:5, where he rebukes the Corinthians for taking legal disputes to secular courts. He also calls the church in Thessalonica to "take note of those who refuse to work" and to "have nothing to do with them," so that they may feel shame and return to right behavior (2 Thessalonians 3:14).

In these instances, shame is a temporary discomfort meant to bring healing, much like surgery. It’s a wake-up call that leads to spiritual growth. Yet, like surgery, it should not last longer than necessary. The end goal of well-placed shame is always restoration, not lingering in guilt.

Moving Beyond Shame

Whether shame is misplaced or well-placed, the path beyond it lies in trusting Christ. Paul reminds us in 2 Timothy 1:12 that he is "not ashamed" because he knows whom he believes Jesus Christ, who guards and redeems him. This trust in Christ's work allows believers to cast off both false shame and the shame of sin, embracing forgiveness.

Romans 10:11 promises, “Everyone who believes in Him will not be put to shame.” No shame misplaced or well-placed can last in the light of eternity with Christ. God intends for us to move past both, finding our true identity in Him.

Ultimately, we must understand shame’s role in our spiritual journey: it can be used by God to draw us nearer to Him when well-placed, but it should never keep us bound. Through Christ’s work on the cross, we are free from eternal shame, restored to honor in God’s kingdom.

If you found this reflection on shame helpful, consider sharing it with others or subscribing to our newsletter for more insights.