The Lie of Comfort in Sin

When life hits hard when you’re weary, hurting, discouraged, or overwhelmed where do you go for relief?

Maybe it’s late at night after another exhausting day, and your mind just wants to numb out. Or maybe you’re dealing with rejection or stress, and the quick-fix comforts call your name. It could be overeating, binge-watching, scrolling endlessly, drinking, complaining, or returning to that sin you swore you’d never touch again.

But whatever it is, here’s the truth: sin will not comfort you. It can’t. It’s incapable of healing your wounds or filling the emptiness. In fact, it does the opposite it pours salt in the wound, making everything feel worse.

This isn’t just theory. This is real, gritty spiritual truth. And until we believe it, we’ll keep reaching for the very things that deepen our pain.

The Sparkling Water of Sin

A personal story helps illustrate this. The author had to cut out gluten due to health reasons and felt much better. But a new wave of symptoms eventually led a doctor to suggest another culprit: sparkling water. What the author thought would soothe his stomach was actually aggravating it. He had been pouring fizz onto pain, thinking it would help.

That’s exactly what sin is like. When life aches, we reach for what we’ve always been told might “settle us.” But instead, it stings. It irritates. It inflames. And we end up feeling worse, wondering why the comfort didn’t work.

Why? Because sin is a counterfeit cure. It’s a broken cistern one that can’t hold water (Jeremiah 2:13). It promises relief and delivers emptiness.

Satan Targets the Hurting

The apostle Peter knew how dangerous this tendency is for Christians especially those who are suffering. He writes:

“Be sober-minded; be watchful. Your adversary the devil prowls around like a roaring lion, seeking someone to devour.” (1 Peter 5:8)

Satan doesn’t wait until you’re strong and thriving to attack. He comes when you’re limping, bleeding, vulnerable. Like a lion, he preys on the weak. And one of his favorite tactics? Tempting you with sin that feels comforting in the moment but cuts deeper in the end.

Peter offers three truths to anchor sufferers in moments of temptation:

1. You Have a Real Enemy

Peter doesn’t downplay spiritual warfare. He reminds us: you have an adversary a lion, not a housecat. And he prowls.

Paul echoes this warning: “We do not wrestle against flesh and blood, but against... the spiritual forces of evil” (Ephesians 6:12). When life feels chaotic, it’s not just random there’s often spiritual sabotage involved.

So when you're hurting, don't forget there’s someone trying to leverage that pain into your downfall. Stay alert. Don’t medicate your wounds with what your enemy is offering.

2. You’re Not Alone in Your Suffering

Peter also says “After you have suffered a little while, the God of all grace... will himself restore, confirm, strengthen, and establish you.” (1 Peter 5:10)

Pain isolates. It convinces us no one else knows, no one else understands. But that’s a lie.

Millions of faithful believers across the world and throughout history have endured similar trials. You are not the only one. And seeing others suffer well can give you courage to keep resisting sin and trusting God.

A 2022 Lifeway Research study found that 64% of believers say they struggle to talk about their suffering within their church community. That’s tragic. Because one of God’s greatest comforts is community. So if you’re hurting, don’t isolate. Reach out. Ask someone to pray with you. You are not alone.

3. Your Pain Has an Expiration Date

Peter continues “After you have suffered a little while, the God of all grace... will himself restore, confirm, strengthen, and establish you.” (1 Peter 5:10)

Don’t miss that a little while. It may feel like forever. The wounds may be deep. But in God’s eyes, it’s temporary. And what’s coming is eternal restoration, strength, and peace. You will be healed. You will be whole.

That doesn’t make your pain less real, but it reframes it. Because when we know how the story ends, we can endure the middle chapters with hope.

Broken Cisterns vs. Living Water

So, what do you reach for when the ache sets in? When stress rises? When loneliness screams?

Jeremiah 2:13 offers a vivid image:

“My people... have forsaken me, the fountain of living waters, and hewed out cisterns for themselves, broken cisterns that can hold no water.”

God is the fountain. Sin is the cracked cup. When you’re thirsty, where will you turn?

Jesus says, “If anyone thirsts, let him come to me and drink” (John 7:37). Only his comfort satisfies. Only his Spirit strengthens. Only his Word speaks peace in the storm.

You can’t just avoid sin. You have to replace it. You need something better. That “something” is Christ.

What’s Your Sparkling Water?

Maybe for you, it’s control. Or distraction. Or anger. Or pornography. Or food. Or isolation. Whatever it is, it’s a cracked cistern. It doesn’t hold water.

So today, ask yourself honestly: What do I turn to for comfort that actually makes things worse? Then ask Jesus to fill that space instead with his peace, his promises, and his people.

Because sin never comforts. But Christ always does.

Share this with someone who needs real comfort or subscribe to our newsletter for more hope-filled content each week.