When It’s Okay to Break the Rules

Rules are an essential part of any society, providing structure and order. However, as Christians, there are moments when we may find ourselves at a crossroads, where following human rules conflicts with our calling to obey God’s higher law. In such situations, it’s important to discern when breaking the rules is not only acceptable but necessary in order to stay true to our faith. Here are four situations where it’s okay to break the rules, as long as we are guided by God’s wisdom and love.

1. When the Rules Conflict with God’s Commands

One of the clearest examples of when it’s acceptable to break the rules is when those rules directly conflict with God’s commands. In Acts 5:29, the apostles Peter and John boldly declared, "We must obey God rather than human beings!" They made this statement after being ordered by the authorities to stop preaching in the name of Jesus. Instead of complying, they chose to follow God’s command to spread the Gospel, even at the risk of imprisonment.

This principle is timeless. When human laws or societal norms require us to act in ways that contradict God’s Word, we are called to obey God above all else. This might mean standing up for justice in the face of unjust laws, refusing to compromise our faith, or choosing to speak the truth even when it’s unpopular. Our ultimate allegiance is to God, and when man-made rules oppose His commands, we must choose to follow Him.

2. When the Rules Hinder Compassion

Jesus often challenged the religious leaders of His day for their rigid adherence to rules at the expense of compassion. One such instance is found in Matthew 12:1-8, where the Pharisees criticized Jesus’ disciples for picking grain on the Sabbath. Jesus responded by reminding them that "The Sabbath was made for man, not man for the Sabbath" (Mark 2:27). He emphasized that the purpose of God’s laws is to promote love and mercy, not to impose burdens.

In our own lives, there may be times when strict adherence to rules can prevent us from showing compassion to others. For example, helping someone in need, even if it means bending or breaking a rule, can be an expression of God’s love. When rules stand in the way of caring for others, it’s important to remember that love and mercy should always take precedence.

3. When the Rules are Unjust

Throughout history, there have been unjust laws and rules that have oppressed individuals or groups. As Christians, we are called to stand against injustice and work towards God’s kingdom of righteousness. The Bible is full of examples of individuals who broke unjust rules in order to pursue justice.

Consider the story of Shadrach, Meshach, and Abednego in Daniel 3. These three young men refused to obey King Nebuchadnezzar’s decree to worship a golden statue, even though the punishment for disobedience was being thrown into a fiery furnace. They chose to honor God rather than submit to an unjust command, and God protected them for their faithfulness.

In today’s world, standing against unjust rules might involve civil disobedience or advocating for change in systems that perpetuate inequality. When faced with unjust rules, we are called to act in a way that reflects God’s justice, even if it means breaking those rules.

4. When the Rules Prevent Us from Doing Good

James 4:17 says, "If anyone, then, knows the good they ought to do and doesn’t do it, it is sin for them." Sometimes, rules or policies can hinder us from doing the good that God has called us to do. In such cases, we must carefully consider whether following the rules would prevent us from fulfilling our God-given responsibilities.

An example of this can be seen in the story of Rahab, found in Joshua 2. Rahab, a resident of Jericho, hid the Israelite spies who were scouting the city, even though it meant defying her own king’s orders. Her actions, motivated by faith in God, ultimately saved her and her family when Jericho fell. Rahab broke the rules because she recognized that protecting God’s people was the greater good.

In our lives, doing good might mean prioritizing God’s work over bureaucratic red tape or choosing to act with integrity even when it means bending the rules. When rules prevent us from doing what we know is right, it may be time to reconsider our allegiance to those rules.

Conclusion

Breaking rules should never be taken lightly, but as Christians, there are times when it is necessary to prioritize God’s higher law over human regulations. Whether it’s in situations where rules conflict with God’s commands, hinder compassion, perpetuate injustice, or prevent us from doing good, our actions must always be guided by faith, wisdom, and love. By seeking God’s guidance, we can discern when breaking the rules is the right thing to do in order to honor Him and advance His kingdom.

Consider sharing this article to help others navigate the difficult decisions they may face, or subscribe to our newsletter for more insights on living out your faith in a complex world.